ProPass vs Substack: Following an Expert vs Working With One

ProPass vs Substack comparison, a ProPass guide

Category :

Comparison

Expert :

ProPass Team

Published :

Updated :

Substack is one of the most popular places to follow writers, thinkers, and experts. ProPass also features experts sharing their knowledge, but it's built for a different relationship. Here's how they compare and when to use each.

Short answer: Substack is built for subscribing to someone's content, mainly newsletters, along with podcasts and video. ProPass is built for discovering vetted experts and working with them directly through 1-on-1 sessions, packages, custom work, and messages. Use Substack to follow an expert's thinking. Use ProPass when you want their help with your specific situation.

What is the difference between ProPass and Substack?

The biggest difference is the relationship. On Substack, you're a reader: you subscribe to a writer's newsletter and read or watch what they publish. On ProPass, you're a client: you find an expert and work with them on your own goals, whether that's a live session, a ready-made package, or custom work.

How does Substack work?

Writers publish newsletters, along with podcasts, video, and short posts. Readers subscribe for free or pay for premium content, and Substack takes a share of paid subscriptions. Substack is one of the best places to build a paid newsletter, with millions of paid subscriptions across the platform and strong tools for writers to grow an audience.

How does ProPass work?

On ProPass, you scroll a feed of posts from vetted experts. When a post resonates with you, you tap through to that expert's profile, where you can book a live 1-on-1 session, buy a package, request custom work, or leave a tip. After a purchase, you can message the expert directly.

How are the feeds different?

Both platforms have a feed, but they work differently. Substack's feed, called Notes, mixes posts from writers and readers, and an algorithm decides what you see. ProPass's feed shows posts only from vetted experts, in chronological order, with no algorithm. And where a post leads is different, too. A Substack note leads to a subscription. A ProPass post leads to an expert's profile, where you can book, buy, or message them.

Are the experts vetted?

Anyone can start a Substack, so it's up to you to judge each writer's background. On ProPass, every expert is vetted before joining, including a screening call with the ProPass team, and not every applicant is accepted.

Can you work with an expert directly?

Substack is built around subscriptions to content, so the relationship centers on reading and listening. ProPass is built for direct work: live video sessions, personalized deliverables, and one-on-one messaging. Most ProPass experts also offer a free 15-minute discovery call, so you can check the fit before you pay.

What can you buy on each platform?

On Substack, you can buy paid subscriptions to newsletters and premium content. On ProPass, you can book live 1-on-1 sessions, buy instant-download digital products like templates and guides, request custom deliverables like audits and personalized plans, tip experts on their posts, and subscribe to ProPass Premium for premium content and unlimited messaging.

When should you use Substack vs ProPass?

Use Substack when you want to follow an expert's writing, stay current on a topic, or support a writer you enjoy. Use ProPass when you want an expert's help with your specific situation, like a session, a plan, or a review of your work. Many experts use both: Substack to share their thinking, and ProPass to work with clients. If you're also comparing other platforms, see our ProPass vs LinkedIn, ProPass vs Fiverr, ProPass vs Upwork, and ProPass vs Clarity.fm comparisons.



Substack

ProPass

Built for

Subscribing to content

Working with vetted experts

Your role

Reader

Client

Feed

Algorithmic, writers and readers post

Chronological, only vetted experts post

Vetting

Anyone can start a Substack

Every expert vetted

Talk before buying

Comments and chat

Most experts offer a free 15-minute call

What you can buy

Paid subscriptions

Sessions, digital packages, custom deliverables, tips, Premium

FAQs

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Is Substack just for newsletters?

  • Newsletters are its core, but Substack also supports podcasts, video, short posts in its Notes feed, and subscriber chat.

Arrow Down Icon
  • Can I book a session with an expert on Substack?

  • Substack is built around subscriptions to content. To book live sessions, buy packages, or request custom work from vetted experts, ProPass is built for that.

Arrow Down Icon
  • How is ProPass's feed different from Substack Notes?

  • Substack Notes is algorithmic and includes posts from writers and readers. ProPass's feed is chronological and shows posts only from vetted experts.

Arrow Down Icon
  • Can experts use both Substack and ProPass?

  • Yes. Many experts use Substack to share their writing and ProPass to work directly with clients through sessions, packages, and custom work.

Arrow Down Icon
  • Should I use ProPass or Substack?

  • Use Substack to follow an expert's writing. Use ProPass when you want a vetted expert's direct help with your specific situation.

Arrow Down Icon